NOTE! This website and the forum are pretty much in archival mode and are often prone to being broken.
If you need something or would like to reconnect with the community reach out to Monkeydog on Discord (username Monkeydog189).
Manga Review: Oyasumi Punpun - Foyer Submissions and Suggestions - Monkey Productions

Jump to content


Photo

Manga Review: Oyasumi Punpun


  • Please log in to reply
6 replies to this topic

#1 rekaru

rekaru

    lovely, lovely

  • Cocoon
  • 1630 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 06 May 2011 - 01:56 PM

This is my first review. Let me know what points I need to improve upon or clarify so that I can make the appropriate amendments. Also, it would be nice to know if any of you actually read this.

Oyasumi Punpun

Posted Image

Punpun, a human boy caricatured as a bird and burdened with the realities of everyday life gradually enters into the real world, an experience that can only be characterized as nightmarish and simultaneously uplifting. The tragedies of everyday life that we tend to sweep to the back of our minds for the sake of our own sanity consistently remain at the forefront of Punpun's mind, and in his interactions with the world, he begins to learn life's hard lessons. He's dealt the short stick in life, and it reflects in the events that are laid out in front of him, but hope and innocence percolate through every now and then, and give him just enough to get by and live. The sliding scale of cynicism versus idealism manifests itself into each of the characters (deadbeat or harbingers of hope) and the drawing style.

The artwork can be very jarring at first. Punpun initially seems very adorable; after all, despite him interacting with humans and living just like a human, he's drawn as a bird. In contrast, everyone else outside of Punpun's family is drawn very realistically, and sometimes just too ugly for it to be slightly creepy. Still, Asano Inio does a fantastic job, and ultimately, this mixture lends itself well to the overwhelming amount of cynicism and surrealism that are ever so pervasive.

Aside from the surrealist bits, Asano Inio crafts very believable and endearing individuals, so much so that as a reader, you may cringe for them in their embarrassing moments, or even feel sadness as you witness a tragedy unfold. The characters and their overactive imaginations create a setup for what can be described as dark humour, but one's reactions to these scenes will arguably depend on how much one sympathizes with those involved. Likely, the more emotionally detached one is from the story, the more likely s/he is able to see the humour and ignore the nightmarish pieces.

The manga, depressing as it is, can be worth reading just for those short, poignant moments of happiness Punpun may feel, and it's this parallel to real life that makes Oyasumi Punpun such an enticing read. It's very premise seems built upon a philosophical anti-nihilist anti-existentialist thesis; that despite what hardships humans may encounter, there is always something in life worth living for until the very end, and that as long as one lives, there exists a possibility for happiness. The manga isn't finished yet, but there are ~80 chapters out, so there's plenty of reading material until the next release.

For the average reader, I would give this a 9/10. If you're into dark humour and painful coming-of-age stories, 10/10. Mark it down a notch if this isn't your genre.
  • 0

#2 Stars

Stars

    Pooka

  • Sex Bob-omb
  • 14199 posts
  • Location:Great American Desert
  • Interests:Various nerdy things.
  • Gender:Male

Posted 06 May 2011 - 05:34 PM

Huh, I haven't heard of this one before. It sounds...strange.

I like the review, though. :D
  • 1

* * * Stars' Final Fantasy Challenge * * *

 

Final Fantasy I - Completion Time 14:11

Final Fantasy II - Completion Time 27:03

Final Fantasy III - Play Time 07:24

Final Fantasy IV - Play Time 04:01

Final Fantasy V

Final Fantasy VI


#3 rekaru

rekaru

    lovely, lovely

  • Cocoon
  • 1630 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 07 May 2011 - 12:13 PM

Thanks, Stars. I'm glad that at least one person read it ^^
  • 0

#4 Chu

Chu

    Goomba

  • Members
  • 2 posts
  • Gender:Female

Posted 01 April 2013 - 10:33 PM

I made an account just to say that I enjoyed this review a lot! I've read and enjoyed Oyasumi Punpun and I felt like you covered everything about the manga perfectly and to the point! You even mentioned things that I never noticed while reading it (the points on the anti-nihilist themes in the story.) It makes me want to re read it. Bravo!
  • 2

#5 lazlo falconi

lazlo falconi

    Knows Nothing

  • YATTAMAN!!
  • 4635 posts
  • Location:Cartoon Hell
  • Interests:Presidency.
  • Gender:Male

Posted 01 April 2013 - 11:10 PM

I made an account just to say that I enjoyed this review a lot! I've read and enjoyed Oyasumi Punpun and I felt like you covered everything about the manga perfectly and to the point! You even mentioned things that I never noticed while reading it (the points on the anti-nihilist themes in the story.) It makes me want to re read it. Bravo!

Welcome to this place. Stay a while, stay forever! We're fun people (Also I'm here)
  • 0

samussig_zpsf75ec25d.png


Or, to put it more politely, "Neener neener."


-all my friends that came with are drinking out in the car
--forever alone
+\- joke's on them i'm too drunk to drive


#6 Monkeydog

Monkeydog

    <3

  • Prince of Zeal
  • 14349 posts
  • Location:The Kingdom of Zeal
  • Interests:Magic
  • Gender:Male

Posted 01 April 2013 - 11:17 PM

I made an account just to say that I enjoyed this review a lot! I've read and enjoyed Oyasumi Punpun and I felt like you covered everything about the manga perfectly and to the point! You even mentioned things that I never noticed while reading it (the points on the anti-nihilist themes in the story.) It makes me want to re read it. Bravo!

Welcome to this place. Stay a while, stay forever! We're fun people (Also I'm here)

Seconded! 

 

Hi new person!


  • 0

#7 Septerra

Septerra

    Bobcat

  • Dutchio Bro
  • 3763 posts
  • Location:DBZ Universe
  • Gender:Male

Posted 02 April 2013 - 12:58 AM

Please post things related to the appearance of our new member Chu here

http://monkeypro.net...me-chu/?p=95037

 

 

@Rekaru: I'll get to reading your review and a piece of the manga when I get home and have less interruptions (at work now)


  • 0

I AM THE HARBRINGER OF THE SPICY ROOSTER APOCALYPSE!
I AM A HYDROGEN BOMB IN A NECKTIE!
I HOLD THE FLAMES OF A THOUSAND COLLAPSED STARS!
I AM...BOBRACHA!


Strange women lying in ponds, distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power, derives from a mandate from the masses!





1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users